Courses / Biology XI (HSSC-I) – FBISE Complete SLO-Based Course
14.1 Evolution and its Evidences
Unit 14 – Evolution · 50 min read · 20 MCQs to check yourself
Homologous vs analogous structures
What drives evolution (B-01)
Evolution is the gradual change in the heritable characteristics of populations over many generations, giving rise to new species. It depends on two things:
- Variation – individuals of a species differ; heritable variation arises from mutations, crossing over, independent assortment and random fertilisation.
- Selection pressures – factors such as predators, disease, competition for food and mates, climate, availability of water that affect survival and reproduction. Individuals whose variations suit the environment survive and reproduce more (natural selection), passing on their alleles; over generations favourable alleles become more common and the population changes.
Darwin's theory of natural selection (Darwin and Wallace, 1858; Origin of Species, 1859)
- Over-production – organisms produce far more offspring than can survive.
- Struggle for existence – competition for limited resources.
- Variation – no two individuals are exactly alike; many variations are heritable.
- Survival of the fittest / natural selection – individuals with favourable variations survive and reproduce.
- Inheritance – favourable variations are passed on and accumulate → origin of new species. Giraffe neck (Darwinian explanation): ancestral giraffes varied in neck length; when lower leaves were scarce, those with longer necks reached higher leaves, survived drought, and produced more offspring; their offspring inherited long necks; over many generations the population came to have long necks.
Evidence from biogeography (B-02)
Biogeography – the study of the geographical distribution of species.
- Species on islands resemble those of the nearest mainland but are distinct – e.g. Darwin's finches on the Galápagos evolved from South American ancestors into 13+ species with different beaks (adaptive radiation).
- Isolated continents have unique fauna: marsupials of Australia (kangaroo, koala) diversified because Australia separated early; placental mammals evolved elsewhere.
- Similar environments in different continents have different (unrelated) species, showing that distribution reflects ancestry and history (continental drift), not just climate.
Evidence from molecular biology (B-03)
- All organisms use DNA/RNA, the same universal genetic code, the same 20 amino acids, ATP, and similar ribosomes – evidence of a common ancestor.
- Comparison of amino acid sequences of common proteins (e.g. cytochrome c, haemoglobin) and DNA/rRNA base sequences: the fewer differences, the more closely related (and the more recent the common ancestor). Cytochrome c of humans and chimpanzees is identical; it differs from rhesus monkey by 1 amino acid, from horse by 12, from yeast by about 44.
- Molecular clocks – rate of mutation used to estimate when species diverged. Human and chimpanzee DNA are about 98–99% identical.
- Shared pseudogenes and retroviral insertions in the same positions.
Homologous and analogous structures; divergent and convergent evolution (B-04)
| Homologous organs | Analogous organs | |
|---|---|---|
| Origin | Same basic structure and embryonic origin (common ancestor) | Different structure and origin |
| Function | Often different | Same function |
| Type of evolution | Divergent evolution – related species become different as they adapt to different environments (adaptive radiation) | Convergent evolution – unrelated species become similar as they adapt to similar environments |
| Examples | Pentadactyl forelimbs – human arm, whale flipper, bat wing, horse leg, bird wing; thorns of Bougainvillea and tendrils of Cucurbita | Wings of insects, birds and bats; eyes of octopus and mammals; fins of fish and flippers of whales/penguins; sweet potato (root) and potato (stem) |
| Vestigial organs (reduced, functionless remnants – appendix, coccyx, wisdom teeth, nictitating membrane) are also homologous structures and support common ancestry. |
Short and long questions
1. What are homologous and analogous structures? Explain how they provide evidence for divergent and convergent evolution with examples.
Model answer
Homologous structures (3 marks): organs with the same basic structure and embryonic origin but often different functions, inherited from a common ancestor. Example: the pentadactyl forelimb – humerus, radius–ulna, carpals, metacarpals and phalanges – in the human arm (grasping), cat leg (walking), whale flipper (swimming), bat wing (flying) and horse leg (running). The common plan has been modified for different ways of life by divergent evolution (adaptive radiation) – related species diverged as they occupied different habitats. Plant example: thorns of Bougainvillea and tendrils of Cucurbita (both modified stems). Vestigial organs (appendix, coccyx) are also homologous. Analogous structures (3 marks): organs with similar function and appearance but different structure and origin; they do not indicate close relationship. Example: wings of insects (chitinous membranes), birds (feathers on forelimb bones) and bats (skin stretched between fingers); eyes of octopus and vertebrates; streamlined shape of shark (fish) and dolphin (mammal). They arise by convergent evolution – unrelated organisms living in similar environments face similar selection pressures and evolve similar adaptations independently.
2. Explain the evolution of the giraffe's neck according to Darwin's theory of natural selection, and contrast it with Lamarck's explanation.
Model answer
Darwin's theory (4 marks): (1) Over-production – giraffes produce more offspring than the food supply can support. (2) Variation – the ancestral population showed natural, heritable variation in neck length (some longer, some shorter). (3) Struggle for existence – during droughts the leaves on lower branches were eaten up; there was competition for food. (4) Natural selection – giraffes with longer necks could reach higher leaves, survived better and produced more offspring; short-necked ones often starved before reproducing. (5) Inheritance – long necks were passed on genetically; over many generations the proportion of long-necked giraffes increased and the average neck length of the population increased. Contrast with Lamarck (2 marks): Lamarck said giraffes stretched their necks during life (use) and passed on this acquired length; Darwin said the variation already existed (genetic) and was selected by the environment. Lamarck's view is rejected because acquired characters are not inherited (Weismann's experiments).
3. Differentiate between convergent and divergent evolution on the basis of homologous and analogous structures.
Model answer
Divergent evolution – related species descended from a common ancestor become different as they adapt to different environments; it produces homologous structures – same basic structure and embryonic origin but different functions, e.g. the pentadactyl forelimbs of human (grasping), bat (flying), whale (swimming), horse (running). Convergent evolution – unrelated species become similar because they adapt to similar environments; it produces analogous structures – similar function but different structure and origin, e.g. wings of insects, birds and bats; streamlined bodies of shark and dolphin; eyes of octopus and humans.
4. Analyse the evidence of evolution that comes from molecular biology.
Model answer
(1) All living organisms use DNA as genetic material, the same universal genetic code, the same 20 amino acids and ATP – pointing to a single common ancestor. (2) Comparison of amino acid sequences of proteins such as cytochrome c and haemoglobin shows that closely related species have fewer differences (human and chimpanzee cytochrome c identical; human and yeast about 44 differences). (3) DNA/rRNA sequence comparisons give the same branching patterns as anatomy and fossils; human–chimp DNA is ~98–99% similar. (4) The number of differences can be used as a molecular clock to estimate when lineages diverged.
5. Discuss the evidence of evolution provided by biogeography.
Model answer
(1) Species on oceanic islands resemble those on the nearest mainland but are different species – e.g. Galápagos finches, descended from South American ancestors and diversified into many species with different beaks (adaptive radiation). (2) Isolated continents have unique groups – Australian marsupials evolved after Australia separated, while placental mammals dominated other continents. (3) Areas with similar climates on different continents have different, unrelated species, showing that species are distributed according to where their ancestors lived and past geographical events (continental drift), not just environment. This pattern is explained only by evolution from common ancestors.
6. Explain that evolution happens due to variation in organisms and the selection pressures they face.
Model answer
Members of a population show variation, much of it heritable, caused by mutation, crossing over, independent assortment and random fertilisation. Organisms produce more offspring than can survive, so they face selection pressures – predators, disease, competition for food and mates, climate. Individuals with variations that suit the environment survive and reproduce more (natural selection) and pass on their favourable alleles. Over many generations these alleles increase in frequency and the characteristics of the population change – this is evolution, which may lead to new species.
This lesson ends with a quiz of 20 MCQs. Open the lesson on PrepOasis to take it and save your progress.
Previous: Unit 13 Review, Checklist and Unit Test · Next: 14.2 Endosymbiotic Theory and Lamarckism
All lessons in Biology XI (HSSC-I) – FBISE Complete SLO-Based Course